$140 for the Onyx Cinder is a tough sell: the ship looks mean on a shelf, but you're paying a steep premium for a Star Wars name and five minifigs doing most of the heavy lifting.
Is the price fair?B-$140 is steep for what lands in the box; this is a B-tier ship with an A-tier price tag.
Will you love it?B-Dark, displayable, and fun enough to build; just don't go in expecting to be blown away.
Holds its value?B-Modest appreciation likely after retirement: not a lock, but not dead money either.
True ValueB-
$116
Street price
$179
Parts value
154%
Ratio
The parts alone are worth about 154% of the street price — the basis for this B- price read.
What you get
Plain bricks
$58
Functional piecescalc
$45
Figures (×5)
$75
BargainThe parts alone are worth more than you pay — $179 of parts for $116.
The Full Take
The Onyx Cinder has a genuinely menacing silhouette: dark, angular, the kind of ship that looks at home in a villain's hangar. At 1325 pieces it's a solid Saturday build, and the minifig selection gives it real display context. The problem is $139.99 for what you get; this is a mid-tier ship asking for flagship money. The build itself doesn't disappoint in the hands, there are enough structural moments to keep an experienced builder engaged, but it's not the kind of technique showcase that justifies the price on its own. Secondary market history on similar Star Wars vehicles suggests a modest hold, maybe a modest gain, which softens the sting a little. If you're a Star Wars collector who needs this ship on the shelf, you'll be satisfied. Everyone else should wait for a sale.